Cardio vs Weights: What’s Best for Women’s Fat Loss?
Many women believe endless cardio is the key to burning fat — but that’s only part of the picture. The truth is, both cardio and strength training have their place, but one is far more powerful for shaping your body, boosting metabolism, and keeping the weight off long-term.
As a personal trainer, I see women wasting hours on the treadmill when they could be getting faster, stronger, and leaner results in less time. Let’s break it down.
Cardio vs Weights: What’s Best for Women’s Fat Loss?
1. The Role of Cardio in Fat Loss
Cardio – whether that’s walking, running, cycling, or classes – burns calories and supports heart health. It’s great for improving endurance and overall fitness.
But here’s the catch: the calorie burn stops when the workout ends. Overdoing cardio can also increase hunger and even lead to muscle loss if you’re not fuelling properly.
👉 Cardio helps with calorie burn, but it’s not the key driver of long-term fat loss.
2. Why Strength Training Wins for Fat Loss
When it comes to transforming your body composition – losing fat while keeping or building lean muscle – strength training is unbeatable.
Here’s why:
- Muscle tissue burns more calories at rest than fat, meaning a faster metabolism.
- Lifting weights tones and shapes your body, rather than just making you smaller.
- You continue to burn calories long after the workout (known as the “afterburn effect”).
👉 Weights don’t just change your body — they change your metabolism.
3. The Power of Combining Both
The best approach for fat loss isn’t cardio or weights, it’s both, in balance.
- Use strength training 3–4 times per week as your foundation.
- Add cardio 1–2 times per week for endurance, energy, and heart health.
- Mix steady-state cardio (like walking or cycling) with short, effective HIIT sessions.
👉 The combination helps you burn fat efficiently while maintaining muscle tone.
4. Why the Scales Don’t Tell the Full Story
Many women panic when the scale doesn’t move after they start lifting. But here’s the thing — muscle weighs the same fat, but it takes up less space.
That means you can get leaner, smaller, and stronger even if your weight stays the same. Strength training changes your shape, not just the number on the scales.
👉 Focus on measurements, progress photos, and how your clothes fit — not just weight.
5. Don’t Be Afraid of the Weights Room
One of the biggest barriers for women is gym intimidation — thinking the weights area is “for men.” It’s not. Strength training is for everyone, and it’s one of the best tools for confidence, health, and fat loss.
Start with the basics: squats, deadlifts, lunges, push-ups, and rows. Learn good form, progress gradually, and you’ll be amazed at how strong you feel — both physically and mentally.
👉 Confidence grows when you stop chasing calorie burn and start chasing strength.
Conclusion
So, cardio vs weights – what’s best for fat loss?
✅ Weights build lean muscle, boost metabolism, and create long-term results.
✅ Cardio supports heart health and burns extra calories.
Together, they’re the perfect team for fat loss, tone, and confidence.
💪 Don’t just lose weight — build strength, shape, and energy that lasts.
Let’s Talk
Want a clear, structured plan that avoids all these mistakes? My coaching programmes give you personalised training, nutrition advice, and support so you can finally see results. Book a free consultation today.
MARLIES FITNESS
Topics
More Posts
Get In Touch
Personal Trainer Exeter
At Marlies Fitness, we believe that fitness is about more than just the hour you spend in the gym — it’s about the choices you make every day that shape a stronger, healthier, and happier you. That’s why we created Insights: a space dedicated to sharing practical advice, expert guidance, and motivation to help you on your journey.
Here you’ll find tips that go beyond workouts and weights. From simple nutrition swaps that make eating well easier, to mindset tools that keep you motivated when life gets busy, our goal is to give you the knowledge you need to succeed — without the confusing jargon or overcomplicated routines.

Gym Anxiety Is Real: How to Start Training When You Feel Self-Conscious
Walking into a gym when you don’t feel “gym-ready” is a special kind of stress.
It’s not just nerves. It’s the feeling that everyone’s watching. That you don’t know what you’re doing. That you’ll pick up the wrong dumbbell, sit on the wrong machine, press the wrong button, and a siren will go off while a staff member gently escorts you back to the car park.

How to Not Quit the Gym After January (5 Tips to Stay Consistent in February)
If You’re Still Here in February… You’re the One Who Gets Results
The people who change their bodies and feel confident long-term aren’t always the ones with the most motivation.
They’re the ones who keep showing up when it’s cold, dark, and they’d rather be horizontal.

A Day in the Life of a Personal Trainer in Exeter (Featuring: An Eye Twitch and Other Gym Traditions)
If you’ve ever wondered what a personal trainer’s day actually looks like, here’s the honest version: it’s part coaching, part therapist, part motivational DJ… and part professional water bottle refiller.
This is a light, behind-the-scenes look at a typical day as a 1-2-1 personal trainer — from early starts and caffeine dependence to the oddly emotional moment when a client nails their first push-up.